Murder in the First Degree

St. Louis First-Degree Murder Defense Lawyers

First-degree murder is the most serious charge in the state of Missouri due to the severe penalties, including the possibility of life imprisonment without parole or the death penalty. With so much at stake, your choice of legal representation is the most important decision you ever make. You need a defense lawyer with a deep understanding of Missouri’s criminal justice system and a proven track record of success in the most demanding criminal cases.

At Frank & Juengel Law Group P.C., our experienced St. Louis criminal defense lawyers know that a vigorous defense starts with a thorough investigation and a clear strategy. We have successfully defended many clients accused of violent crimes, including first-degree and second murder, by challenging the evidence, questioning witness credibility, and presenting compelling arguments in court. We tailor our defense strategy to the specific facts of your case and explore every angle to protect your rights and future.

Facing a charge as serious as first-degree murder can be overwhelming. With our team by your side, you don’t have to face it alone. Call us today or complete our contact form for a consultation.

Definition of First-Degree Murder in Missouri

Missouri law defines first-degree murder as knowingly causing someone else’s death “after deliberation upon the matter.” “Knowingly” means the defendant fully understood that their actions would result in someone’s death. It’s not about accidentally causing harm; it’s about the person understanding the consequences of their actions and going through with them anyway.

“Deliberation” is one of the critical elements that separates first-degree murder from second-degree murder in Missouri. In this context, deliberation means the defendant thought about the act before committing it, even briefly. It indicates that the killing was premeditated or planned, rather than a spontaneous or impulsive act.

For example, if someone decides to kill another person, even if they only make that decision moments before the act, their actions might qualify as first-degree murder because they took some time to think about the act. This premeditated intent to kill is what makes first-degree murder the most severe homicide charge under Missouri law.

Penalties for First-Degree Murder in Missouri

In Missouri, anyone found guilty of first-degree murder who was 18 or older at the time of the offense will face either the death penalty or life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. For defendants under the age of 18 at the time of the crime, the penalties are different.

Missouri law provides a range of sentencing options for people under 18 if a jury convicts them of first-degree murder. The penalties in these cases range from life imprisonment with or without parole to a prison sentence ranging from 30 to 40 years. When determining the appropriate sentence for a minor, the court must consider various factors, such as the defendant’s age, maturity, mental and emotional development, and the circumstances of the offense. The court also assesses the defendant’s potential for rehabilitation and the impact of familial or peer pressure. These considerations help ensure that the punishment reflects both the gravity of the crime and the unique characteristics of the youthful offender. It’s important to note that in most cases of juveniles charged with first-degree murder, they are certified to stand trial as adults, which significantly impacts the legal proceedings and potential sentencing outcomes.

Common Defenses to First-Degree Murder Charges in Missouri

When facing a first-degree murder charge, a robust defense strategy is crucial. Here are some common defenses that an experienced attorney might employ:

  • Self-Defense: If you reasonably believed your life was in imminent danger, the use of deadly force may be justified. Your attorney will need to demonstrate that you had a genuine fear for your life and that your actions were proportionate to the threat.
  • Defense of Others: Similar to self-defense, if you were protecting another person from imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm, this could serve as a valid defense.
  • Lack of Premeditation: First-degree murder requires premeditation. If your attorney can show that the act was not planned or premeditated, it could result in a reduction to second-degree murder or manslaughter charges.
  • Insanity: While rarely successful, this defense argues that you were not mentally competent at the time of the crime and therefore cannot be held responsible for your actions.
  • Mistaken Identity: Your lawyer may argue that you were wrongly identified as the perpetrator, challenging eyewitness testimony or presenting alibi evidence.
  • Insufficient Evidence: The prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Your attorney may argue that the evidence presented falls short of this high standard.

Each case is unique, and the appropriate defense strategy will depend on the specific circumstances surrounding the charges. A skilled criminal defense attorney will carefully evaluate all aspects of your case to determine the most effective approach.

Defense Strategies in First-Degree Murder Cases

Your legal team will explore every possible angle to challenge a first-degree murder charge. One common strategy is to question the evidence, such as challenging the reliability of witness testimony, forensic evidence, or the procedures used during the investigation. If any part of the evidence against you is flawed, it could weaken the prosecution’s case.

Another key strategy is to argue that the act wasn’t premeditated, which could reduce the charge from first-degree murder to a lesser offense like second-degree murder or manslaughter. Your attorney might also explore self-defense or defense of others if there’s evidence that you acted to protect yourself or someone else from harm.

Additionally, your legal team could focus on showing that you didn’t have the intent to kill or that your actions were influenced by external factors, such as mental illness or coercion. Each case is unique, so your attorney will tailor the defense strategy to the specific circumstances of your situation.

What to Do if You Face a First-Degree Murder Charge

Before you are even arrested, your actions can significantly affect your case and your ability to defend yourself against a first-degree murder charge. Here’s what to do to protect your rights:

  • Exercise your right to remain silent and do not discuss your case with anyone, including the police.
  • Immediately assert your right to counsel and do not answer any questions until your attorney arrives.
  • Avoid speaking about your case over the phone or in writing, as the police can monitor these communications and jail calls are recorded.
  • Do not under any circumstances consent to searches of your home, car or devices. Never ever give passcodes to phones or computers or other devices without getting legal advice first.  Even if they have a search warrant.
  • Provide your attorney with all the details and facts related to your case.
  • Follow your attorney’s advice and instructions closely, especially regarding court appearances and legal procedures.
  • Do not discuss your case on social media or with anyone other than your lawyer.
  • Gather any evidence or information that could support your defense and share it with your attorney.
  • Attend all scheduled court appearances and meetings with your lawyer to stay informed about your case if you have been fortunate enough to make bond.
  • Stay calm and trust your legal team to guide you through the process.

Contact a St. Louis First-Degree Murder Defense Attorney Now

It’s crucial to contact a lawyer as soon as possible after your arrest, so your legal team can start building your defense. The defense attorneys Frank & Juengel Law Group P.C., know the pressure you’re under and can guide you through this complex legal process. Call us today or complete our contact form for a consultation.